Caputo named Fort Erie CAO days after McQueen firing

Krystle Caputo has been named Fort Erie’s new chief administrative officer, two days after Mayor Tom Insinna used his strong mayor powers to fire Chris McQueen.

The Town of Fort Erie announced Caputo’s appointment Friday. She will take over the municipality’s top administrative job Monday, November 23.

According to the town, Caputo will be responsible for leading municipal administration and implementing council priorities, with an initial focus that includes health-care advocacy, service delivery, economic growth and organizational performance.

“Krystle brings the experience, energy and collaborative approach to help move Fort Erie forward,” Insinna said in the release.

Insinna said he believes the town makes its strongest decisions through consensus and described Caputo as someone capable of building partnerships and turning complex issues into action.

Credit: Krystle Caputo | LinkedIn

The appointment comes during a turbulent first week for the new council.

Insinna dismissed McQueen Wednesday less than 48 hours after being sworn in as mayor, using provincial strong mayor powers that allow the mayor to make the decision without council approval.

Several councillors publicly criticized both the decision and the process. Ward 5 Councillor Tom Lewis subsequently launched a petition asking Insinna to voluntarily give up his strong mayor powers.

McQueen had served as CAO since 2022.

Caputo’s appointment also confirms reporting published Thursday by the St. Catharines Standard.

Citing multiple unnamed sources, the Standard reported Caputo was expected to be named Fort Erie’s next CAO as early as this week.

One anonymous source told the Standard several councillors were concerned about Caputo’s lack of municipal management experience and alleged the appointment appeared to have been made without a competitive recruitment process or formal evaluation of candidates.

The town’s announcement Friday did not say whether a competitive search was conducted.

Ward 2 Councillor Nick Dubanow told the Standard he had concerns about the hiring process and its transparency, while Lewis said council had not been consulted.

Caputo brings extensive government, communications and government-relations experience, although her publicly documented career does not include a previous municipal CAO position.

Her Queen’s Park career has included senior roles in ministerial offices under Ontario’s Progressive Conservative government.

Ontario legislative records show Caputo served as chief of staff to Children, Community and Social Services ministers Merrilee Fullerton and Michael Parsa. She had previously worked in the office of then-Municipal Affairs and Housing Minister Steve Clark, including as director of communications.

The Standard reported Caputo returned to the Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing in January as a special advisor.

She also has previous ties to Niagara.

Caputo worked at the Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority, eventually serving as director of communications and administration.

Her time there overlapped with a period of significant governance and management changes at the authority, including a 2018 special audit by Ontario’s auditor general. The audit examined the organization and its governance and did not single out Caputo personally.

After leaving provincial government in 2023, Caputo joined ONpoint Strategy Group as a senior consultant.

Federal lobbying records show she later registered as a consultant lobbyist for several clients, including Cargojet, Nickel Developments, Lullaboo Nurseries and Childcare and the Canadian Urban Transit Research and Innovation Consortium. The Standard also identified real estate developer Spotlight Development as one of her former clients.

The Standard reported Caputo did not respond to its questions about whether any former lobbying clients had interests in Fort Erie or elsewhere in Niagara.

Caputo holds a communications degree from Brock University and was named one of Niagara’s 40 Under Forty recipients in 2021.

“Good municipal government comes down to people, supporting the staff who serve our community and earning the trust of the residents who count on us,” Caputo said in the town’s release.

She said she plans to work with council and town staff to make municipal government more responsive and strengthen partnerships.

Stay Informed

Events, offers, contests, and breaking news, all delivered straight to your inbox.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *